Starlight Shores requires 2 playthroughs and 2 save files to efficiently reach all of the ending outcomes in the walkthrough.
Ending #1 – Lena Ending
First Playthrough
Marshmallows
Get to know Lena
Beer
I’ve never cheated
“I’m sorry that I didn’t call more.”
Say something
Truth
Tell the truth
Marshmallows
Encourage Theo
Gather Firewood with Lena
I don’t want to publish them
Physical Insecurity
Theo
“What would you change about your life?”
“You’re being a terrible boyfriend.”
Truth
Stop Theo
Walk with Lena
Yes
Second Playthrough – Common Route
Hot Dogs
Talk about Theo
Go alone
Beer
I’ve never shoplifted
“You’ll never lose me.”
Be quiet
Truth
Jello Shot
Hot Dogs
Encourage Theo
Save 1
Ending #2 – Alec Ending
Stay with Alec
“Do you want to talk about Erika?”
Jello Shot
Lena
“What’s the worst thing you’ve ever done?”
“It doesn’t count.”
“I’m lost.”
“I don’t know what to say.”
“It’s not about how I feel.”
“We’re only friends.”
Red hair
First kiss
Gymnastics
Save 2
Play Alec’s game
Soccer
Ending #3 – Meant To Be
Load Save 2
Pass
Go to bed
Ending #4 – Theo Ending
Load Save 1
Gather Firewood with Theo
“We don’t need a fire to stargaze.”
“I’m sorry that I brought Alec.”
“Let’s go on a road trip.”
Physical Insecurity
Theo
“What would you change about your life?”
Say nothing
Truth
Stop Theo
Yes
